| York City FC v Dorking Wanderers 02/12/2023 | View match | |
| Rochdale FC v York City FC 16/12/2023 | View match | |
| York City FC v Ebbsfleet United 23/12/2023 | View match | |
| Gateshead v York City FC 26/12/2023 | View match | |
| York City FC v Gateshead 01/01/2024 | View match | |
| Boreham Wood v York City FC 06/01/2024 | View match | |
| York City FC v AFC Fylde 20/01/2024 | View match | |
| Oxford City FC v York City FC 23/01/2024 | View match | |
| Hartlepool United v York City FC 27/01/2024 | View match | |
| York City FC v Maidenhead United 03/02/2024 | View match | |
| Southend United FC v York City FC 10/02/2024 | View match | |
| York City FC v Dagenham & Redbridge 17/02/2024 | View match |