| Lancaster City v Whitby Town 16/09/2023 | View match | |
| FC United Of Manchester v Whitby Town 23/09/2023 | View match | |
| Whitby Town v Marske United 26/09/2023 | View match | |
| Whitby Town v Gainsborough 30/09/2023 | View match | |
| Hyde United v Whitby Town 14/10/2023 | View match | |
| Whitby Town v Matlock Town 21/10/2023 | View match | |
| Bradford Park Avenue v Whitby Town 23/10/2023 | View match | |
| Radcliffe Borough v Whitby Town 28/10/2023 | View match | |
| Whitby Town v Stafford Rangers 04/11/2023 | View match | |
| Bristol Rovers FC v Whitby Town 04/11/2023 | View match | |
| Macclesfield Town FC v Whitby Town 11/11/2023 | View match | |
| Whitby Town v Bamber Bridge 18/11/2023 | View match |