| Blackburn Olympic v Partick Thistle FC 23/10/1886 | View match | |
| Chirk F.C. v Hartford St Johns 23/10/1886 | View match | |
| Clapton F.C v Crusaders FC (Belfast) 23/10/1886 | View match | |
| Darwen Old Wanderers v Cowlairs 23/10/1886 | View match | |
| Leek Town v Druids F.C 23/10/1886 | View match | |
| Lincoln Lindum v Grantham Town 23/10/1886 | View match | |
| Luton Town FC v Hotspur 23/10/1886 | View match | |
| Old Carthusians v Reading FC 23/10/1886 | View match | |
| Oswaldtwistle Rovers v Witton Albion 23/10/1886 | View match | |
| Rochester v Marlow FC 23/10/1886 | View match | |
| Swifts v Luton Wanderers 23/10/1886 | View match | |
| Upton Park v 1st Surrey Rifles 23/10/1886 | View match |