| Southampton FC v Rotherham United FC 11/05/1963 | £4.50 | |
| Bury FC v Rotherham United FC 24/08/1963 | £8.00 | |
| Rotherham United FC v Manchester City FC 31/08/1963 | £11.50 | |
| Manchester City FC v Rotherham United FC 21/12/1963 | £5.00 | |
| Sunderland FC v Rotherham United FC 27/03/1964 | £9.99 | |
| Preston North End FC v Rotherham United FC 22/08/1964 | £2.50 | |
| Preston North End FC v Rotherham United FC 22/08/1964 | £3.00 | |
| Manchester City FC v Rotherham United FC 03/10/1964 | £5.00 | |
| Newcastle United FC v Rotherham United FC 07/11/1964 | £7.99 | |
| Southampton FC v Rotherham United FC 21/11/1964 | £8.50 | |
| Rotherham United FC v West Ham United FC 03/11/1965 | £13.50 | |
| Manchester City FC v Rotherham United FC 28/12/1965 | £6.50 |