| Acton v Old Carthusians 08/11/1879 | View match | |
| Wanderers v Old Carthusians 10/01/1880 | View match | |
| Blackburn Olympic v Old Carthusians 17/03/1883 | View match | |
| Reading Minster v Old Carthusians 10/11/1883 | View match | |
| Acton v Old Carthusians 08/11/1884 | View match | |
| Church v Old Carthusians 14/02/1885 | View match | |
| Blackburn Rovers FC v Old Carthusians 07/03/1885 | View match | |
| Chatham Town v Old Carthusians 31/10/1885 | View match | |
| Leek Town v Old Carthusians 05/02/1887 | View match | |
| Watford Rovers v Old Carthusians 05/11/1887 | View match | |
| West Bromwich Albion FC v Old Carthusians 28/01/1888 | View match | |
| Wolverhampton Wanderers FC v Old Carthusians 02/02/1889 | View match |