| Sunderland FC v Barnsley FC 16/09/1986 | View match | |
| Barnsley FC v Plymouth Argyle FC 20/09/1986 | View match | |
| Barnsley FC v Tottenham Hotspur FC 23/09/1986 | View match | |
| Grimsby Town FC v Barnsley FC 27/09/1986 | View match | |
| Birmingham City FC v Barnsley FC 04/10/1986 | View match | |
| Tottenham Hotspur FC v Barnsley FC 08/10/1986 | £2.50 | |
| Barnsley FC v Bradford City FC 11/10/1986 | View match | |
| Brighton & Hove Albion FC v Barnsley FC 18/10/1986 | View match | |
| Barnsley FC v Sheffield United FC 25/10/1986 | View match | |
| Barnsley FC v Blackburn Rovers FC 01/11/1986 | View match | |
| Reading FC v Barnsley FC 08/11/1986 | View match | |
| Barnsley FC v Derby County FC 15/11/1986 | View match |